THE ONE CAPABILITY MOST HIRING PROCESSES FAIL TO ASSESS — AND WHY IT MATTERS
When organisations think about hiring, they still tend to default to the usual suspects: experience, qualifications, technical capability, and “can they do the job?” All important. But incomplete. Because the reality is this: you can train skills. You can’t easily train how someone shows up with people. And in the for-purpose and social impact sector, that distinction matters even more.
Emotional intelligence (EQ) — the ability to understand and manage your own emotions, and respond effectively to the emotions of others — is increasingly one of the strongest predictors of workplace success. It shows up in how people handle pressure, navigate conflict, build trust, and lead others through uncertainty.
It’s also one of the most commonly under-assessed capabilities in recruitment. And that gap is costing organisations more than they realise: misalignment in teams, avoidable conflict, poor leadership fit, and candidates who look great on paper but struggle in practice.
So how do you hire for something that’s harder to measure than a qualification? You stop relying on assumptions — and you start designing for it.
What emotional intelligence actually looks like at work
Emotional intelligence isn’t abstract. It shows up in very observable behaviours:
In recruitment contexts, emotionally intelligent candidates tend to demonstrate stronger communication, better self-awareness, and more thoughtful relationship-building — all of which translate into better long-term performance and team cohesion.
Research consistently shows that these “soft skills” are not soft at all; they are central to effective collaboration and leadership.
The problem: most interviews don’t actually test EQ
Here’s the uncomfortable truth. Most interview processes are still designed to assess:
Not how they behave under real conditions. Which is exactly where emotional intelligence lives.
As a result, candidates can often “perform well” in interviews without ever being meaningfully tested on empathy, adaptability, or interpersonal judgment. And that’s where structured behavioural interviewing becomes critical — not as a buzzword, but as a method.
Instead of asking “Are you a good leader?”, you ask “Tell me about a time you had to manage a team member who wasn’t meeting expectations. What did you do, and what happened?”
The difference is everything. Because emotional intelligence doesn’t show up in claims. It shows up in stories, detail, and reflection.
Five practical ways to hire for emotional intelligence
Based on what we see across social impact hiring, here are five approaches that consistently work better than intuition alone:
1. Ask for real behavioural examples (not hypotheticals)
Past behaviour is still one of the strongest indicators of future behaviour. Structured, situational questions are essential.
2. Listen for accountability, not just outcomes
Emotionally intelligent candidates don’t just describe success — they can reflect on what they learned, and where they adapted.
3. Pay attention to how they talk about others
Language matters. Do they demonstrate empathy, respect, and nuance — or blame and oversimplification?
4. Use consistent interview frameworks
Without structure, bias fills the gap. With structure, you get comparability and fairness.
5. Bring referees into the EQ assessment properly
Not just “were they good?” but “how did they behave when things were difficult?”
Where most organisations fall short
Even with the right intent, many hiring processes still struggle because:
Which means decisions often default back to familiarity, confidence, or charisma — none of which are reliable indicators of emotional intelligence.
How Social Impact Careers helps
This is where we work differently. At Social Impact Careers, we don’t just help you find candidates — we help you design better hiring processes so you can actually assess what matters.
As part of our recruitment process, we work with organisations to:
Because the quality of your hire is only ever as strong as the quality of your process. And if emotional intelligence matters in your organisation — it needs to be deliberately designed into how you hire for it.
Final thought
Skills get someone in the door. Emotional intelligence determines how they show up once they’re inside. And the organisations that get this right aren’t guessing in interviews — they’re designing for better decisions from the start.
About the author
Lisa Morell is a trusted advisor, founder and people strategist with deep experience helping organisations make better hiring decisions — especially where the cost of a wrong hire is high.
Lisa has worked closely with boards, executives and purpose-driven organisations to design recruitment processes that go beyond CVs and gut instinct, focusing instead on values alignment, cultural fit and real-world capability. She’s known for her practical, no-nonsense approach to interviewing — and for asking the questions others often don’t.
Lisa brings clarity, rigour and humanity to the hiring process, helping organisations find people who don’t just look good on paper, but genuinely belong in the role.
Get in touch
If you’d like support with recruitment strategy, executive hiring, interview design or related questions, Lisa would love to hear from you.
Lisa Morell
Director, Social Impact Careers
lisa@socialimpactcareers.com.au
0431 874 400
Emotional intelligence (EQ) — the ability to understand and manage your own emotions, and respond effectively to the emotions of others — is increasingly one of the strongest predictors of workplace success. It shows up in how people handle pressure, navigate conflict, build trust, and lead others through uncertainty.
It’s also one of the most commonly under-assessed capabilities in recruitment. And that gap is costing organisations more than they realise: misalignment in teams, avoidable conflict, poor leadership fit, and candidates who look great on paper but struggle in practice.
So how do you hire for something that’s harder to measure than a qualification? You stop relying on assumptions — and you start designing for it.
What emotional intelligence actually looks like at work
Emotional intelligence isn’t abstract. It shows up in very observable behaviours:
- How someone responds when they’re challenged or under pressure
- Whether they can take feedback without defensiveness
- How they treat people they don’t “need” something from
- Whether they can read a room and adjust their approach
- How they handle conflict without escalation or avoidance
In recruitment contexts, emotionally intelligent candidates tend to demonstrate stronger communication, better self-awareness, and more thoughtful relationship-building — all of which translate into better long-term performance and team cohesion.
Research consistently shows that these “soft skills” are not soft at all; they are central to effective collaboration and leadership.
The problem: most interviews don’t actually test EQ
Here’s the uncomfortable truth. Most interview processes are still designed to assess:
- what someone knows
- what they’ve done
- how they describe themselves
Not how they behave under real conditions. Which is exactly where emotional intelligence lives.
As a result, candidates can often “perform well” in interviews without ever being meaningfully tested on empathy, adaptability, or interpersonal judgment. And that’s where structured behavioural interviewing becomes critical — not as a buzzword, but as a method.
Instead of asking “Are you a good leader?”, you ask “Tell me about a time you had to manage a team member who wasn’t meeting expectations. What did you do, and what happened?”
The difference is everything. Because emotional intelligence doesn’t show up in claims. It shows up in stories, detail, and reflection.
Five practical ways to hire for emotional intelligence
Based on what we see across social impact hiring, here are five approaches that consistently work better than intuition alone:
1. Ask for real behavioural examples (not hypotheticals)
Past behaviour is still one of the strongest indicators of future behaviour. Structured, situational questions are essential.
2. Listen for accountability, not just outcomes
Emotionally intelligent candidates don’t just describe success — they can reflect on what they learned, and where they adapted.
3. Pay attention to how they talk about others
Language matters. Do they demonstrate empathy, respect, and nuance — or blame and oversimplification?
4. Use consistent interview frameworks
Without structure, bias fills the gap. With structure, you get comparability and fairness.
5. Bring referees into the EQ assessment properly
Not just “were they good?” but “how did they behave when things were difficult?”
Where most organisations fall short
Even with the right intent, many hiring processes still struggle because:
- interview questions vary wildly between panel members
- EQ is “felt for” rather than assessed
- there’s no shared definition of what good looks like
- behavioural signals aren’t systematically captured
Which means decisions often default back to familiarity, confidence, or charisma — none of which are reliable indicators of emotional intelligence.
How Social Impact Careers helps
This is where we work differently. At Social Impact Careers, we don’t just help you find candidates — we help you design better hiring processes so you can actually assess what matters.
As part of our recruitment process, we work with organisations to:
- design structured, behaviour-based interview frameworks
- define what emotional intelligence looks like in your specific role
- build consistent scoring criteria across interview panels
- create questions that genuinely test capability, not just narrative
- reduce bias in how “fit” is assessed
Because the quality of your hire is only ever as strong as the quality of your process. And if emotional intelligence matters in your organisation — it needs to be deliberately designed into how you hire for it.
Final thought
Skills get someone in the door. Emotional intelligence determines how they show up once they’re inside. And the organisations that get this right aren’t guessing in interviews — they’re designing for better decisions from the start.
About the author
Lisa Morell is a trusted advisor, founder and people strategist with deep experience helping organisations make better hiring decisions — especially where the cost of a wrong hire is high.
Lisa has worked closely with boards, executives and purpose-driven organisations to design recruitment processes that go beyond CVs and gut instinct, focusing instead on values alignment, cultural fit and real-world capability. She’s known for her practical, no-nonsense approach to interviewing — and for asking the questions others often don’t.
Lisa brings clarity, rigour and humanity to the hiring process, helping organisations find people who don’t just look good on paper, but genuinely belong in the role.
Get in touch
If you’d like support with recruitment strategy, executive hiring, interview design or related questions, Lisa would love to hear from you.
Lisa Morell
Director, Social Impact Careers
lisa@socialimpactcareers.com.au
0431 874 400
PROUD TO HAVE PARTNERED WITH THESE LEADING
ORGANISATIONS TO DELIVER RESULTS
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
